A lot of reactions on this Coverjunkie post.
To add two more covers on this topic:
Above cover 1: Obama in white, as the messiah.
Photography Martin Dijkstra.
And cover 2: (this one gave the most commotion) Obama pictured as God:
walking on water. Illustration Overburen.
This was a split-run cover series of 4 covers of Intermediair magazine
out of 2008 out of the Netherlands. (note: published right before the final results of the elections)
Read the link on Fox News: Obama pictured as Lord Shiva.